Fourth Man in the Fire Menu Prices Canada 2026
Fourth Man in the Fire Menu Prices Canada 2026
Fourth Man in the Fire menu prices in Canada (checked October 22, 2026): 18-inch whole pizzas $25 to $33.50, slices $7, the deep-fried Ponzo calzone $21.50 to $30.50, hero sandwiches $11.49 to $16.99, and fresh daily Harry and Heels donuts from $14.85. This is the Dundas West spot from the guy behind The Burger’s Priest, and honestly the menu reads like he took everything he learned about hype and applied it to pizza. All prices CAD. If you are comparing Ontario pies, the Mamma’s Pizza menu prices in Ontario guide is worth a look too.
Quick answer: A whole 18-inch pizza at Fourth Man in the Fire Toronto costs $25 to $33.50. Slices are $7. The famous Ponzo (deep-fried calzone) is $21.50 small or $30.50 large. Heroes run $11.49 to $16.99. Donuts from $14.85.
🍕 How Much Is Pizza at Fourth Man in the Fire?
Eighteen inches. 00 flour. San Marzano sauce. These are big, proper pies, not the sad personal-size situation. The Margherita at $25 is the move if you want the classic done right. Pepperoni at $28 is the crowd pick. And the Sausage Onion Hot Honey at $28.25? That is the one I keep coming back to on this menu. Hot honey on pizza works. I was not sure until I tried it somewhere else. Now I get it.
Build Your Own 18-inch at $33.50 is the most expensive whole pie on the board. Worth it? Only if you are picky about toppings. Otherwise the set pies give you more character for less money. Also worth a look: Brooklyn Squares at $29.25, the Sicilian-style squares that people in Toronto talk about more than almost anything else on this menu.
| Pizza (18-inch whole pies) | Price |
|---|---|
| Margherita | $25.00 |
| American Cheese | $25.00 |
| Build Your Own 14-inch | $25.00 |
| Gluten-Free BYO 12-inch | $25.75 |
| Roasted Vegetable | $27.25 |
| Garlic and Mushroom | $27.25 |
| Meatball and Bell Pepper | $27.75 |
| Pepperoni | $28.00 |
| Sausage Onion Hot Honey | $28.25 |
| BBQ Chicken Pizza | $28.25 |
| Pepperoni Mushroom | $28.50 |
| Brooklyn Squares (Sicilian-style) | $29.25 |
| Hawaiian | $29.75 |
| Build Your Own 18-inch | $33.50 |
Just want a slice? Both slices on the board are $7 flat. Pepperoni or Margherita. Seven bucks for a slice in Toronto in 2026 is honestly decent. I have paid more for worse near the Eaton Centre.
| Pizza Slices | Price |
|---|---|
| Pepperoni Slice | $7.00 |
| Margherita Slice | $7.00 |
Fourth Man in the Fire Menu Card Canada 2026
The current Fourth Man in the Fire menu board: 18-inch pies, Ponzo, heroes and donuts, in CAD.
🤲 What Is the Ponzo? Plus Heroes, Salads and Apps
The Ponzo is the headliner here. A deep-fried calzone. Small at $21.50, large at $30.50. Fried calzones are not exactly common in Toronto, which is probably why people make the trip. If you only order one thing and you are feeling adventurous, make it this. Crisp outside, molten inside. That is the whole pitch.
| Ponzo (deep-fried calzone) | Price |
|---|---|
| Small Ponzo | $21.50 |
| Large Ponzo | $30.50 |
The heroes are priced like lunch food, which they basically are. $11.49 across the board for the Real American Hero, Meatball Hero and Caprese Hero. The Chicken Parmesan alla Vodka at $16.99 is the step up. My read? The heroes are the sleeper value on this menu. An $11.49 sandwich in downtown Toronto that actually fills you up is getting harder to find.
| Hero Sandwiches | Price |
|---|---|
| Real American Hero | $11.49 |
| Meatball Hero | $11.49 |
| Caprese Hero | $11.49 |
| Chicken Parmesan alla Vodka | $16.99 |
Salads and appetizers round out the sides. The Caesar at $19.79 is pricey for a salad, no way around it. The Spicy Olives at $5.99 are a cheap add-on if you are snacking. Mozzarella Sticks at $12.49 and Looney Sticks at $11.99 are what they are. Comfort food sides, priced like it.
| Salads & Appetizers | Price |
|---|---|
| Spicy Olives | $5.99 |
| Looney Sticks | $11.99 |
| Mozzarella Sticks | $12.49 |
| Caprese Salad | $17.99 |
| Caesar Salad | $19.79 |
🍩 Harry and Heels Donuts, Cinnamon Rolls and Dessert
This is where the menu gets fun. Harry and Heels California Donuts is an in-house donut program, made fresh daily. A 3-pack is $14.85, a half dozen $29.90, a full dozen $59.85. I have seen pizza places try desserts before and it usually ends at tiramisu. Fresh daily donuts made in-house is a different level of commitment. Respect.
| Harry and Heels California Donuts | Price |
|---|---|
| 3 Pack Assorted | $14.85 |
| Half Dozen Assorted Donuts | $29.90 |
| Dozen Assorted Donuts | $59.85 |
Then there are The Eighth Son cinnamon rolls. A side of cream cheese frosting at $4.99, a frozen 4-pack at $47.96, and a frozen 8-inch giant cinnamon roll at $25.99 that serves six. Frozen might sound odd, but it means you bake it fresh at home. Smart.
| The Eighth Son Cinnamon Rolls | Price |
|---|---|
| Side of Cream Cheese Frosting | $4.99 |
| Frozen 8-inch Giant Cinnamon Roll (serves 6) | $25.99 |
| Frozen Cinnamon Rolls (4 Pack) | $47.96 |
The homemade coconut cream pie has appeared on this menu at $12.99 on earlier versions of the brand’s online menu. I could not confirm it on the current board, so check when you order. If it is there, it is a dessert worth getting.
| Drinks & Dips | Price |
|---|---|
| Chili Flakes | $0.39 |
| Chili Infused Olive Oil | $2.49 |
| Soda and Water | $3.09 |
| Extra Caesar Dressing | $3.09 |
| Creamy Garlic | $3.89 |
| Marinara | $3.89 |
| Hot Honey | $4.09 |
Grab the hot honey dip at $4.09 if you get a slice. Chili flakes at 39 cents are the cheapest thing on this entire menu, and honestly the right move on a pepperoni slice.
Fourth Man in the Fire Pizza Prices Toronto
The 18-inch pies at Fourth Man in the Fire: 00 flour dough, San Marzano sauce.
💡 Is Fourth Man in the Fire Worth the Price?
Short answer: yes, if you like your pizza with some personality. The 18-inch pies at $25 to $33.50 are fairly priced for what they are. These are not thin, sad delivery pizzas. And the whole concept is fun: you order from a tablet at your table, prepay, and summon drinks on a bar cart with a light-up button. Gimmicky? A little. Fun? Also yes.
Where I land: the Ponzo is the reason to go at least once. The heroes are the everyday value. The donuts are the surprise. The Toronto pizza scene has plenty of options, and if you want a completely different style of pie the Pizzaiolo menu prices in Toronto guide covers one of the city’s other big names. But nothing else is doing the fried calzone thing.
📍 Where to Find Fourth Man in the Fire in Toronto
One location: 832 Dundas Street West, Toronto, ON M6J 1V3, phone (416) 792-3473. Per a restaurant listing, hours run daily 11:00 am to 9:30 pm, with Friday and Saturday open till 10:30 pm. Worth double-checking before a late-night run, since listing hours can lag the real board.
❓ Fourth Man in the Fire Menu Prices Canada FAQ
What are Fourth Man in the Fire menu prices in Canada?
Fourth Man in the Fire menu prices in Canada (checked October 22, 2026, all CAD): 18-inch whole pizzas run $25 to $33.50, pizza slices are $7, the deep-fried Ponzo calzone is $21.50 to $30.50, hero sandwiches are $11.49 to $16.99, and Harry and Heels donuts run $14.85 for a 3-pack up to $59.85 for a dozen.
How much is an 18-inch pizza at Fourth Man in the Fire?
An 18-inch whole pizza at Fourth Man in the Fire runs $25 to $33.50, checked October 22, 2026. The Margherita and American Cheese are $25 each, the Pepperoni is $28, and Build Your Own 18-inch tops the list at $33.50. Slices are $7 if you just want a quick one.
What is a Ponzo at Fourth Man in the Fire?
A Ponzo is Fourth Man in the Fire’s deep-fried calzone, and it is the thing people come back for. The small is $21.50 and the large is $30.50, checked October 22, 2026. Think calzone, but fried. Crisp outside, molten inside.
Where is Fourth Man in the Fire in Toronto?
Fourth Man in the Fire is at 832 Dundas Street West, Toronto, ON M6J 1V3, phone (416) 792-3473. It runs daily 11:00 am to 9:30 pm, with Friday and Saturday open till 10:30 pm. For another Ontario pizza night, the Score Pizza menu prices in Ontario guide covers a different style of pie.
Does Fourth Man in the Fire have gluten-free pizza?
Yes. The menu includes a Gluten-Free Build Your Own 12-inch pizza at $25.75, checked October 22, 2026. Worth confirming with the store when you order, since gluten-free prep setups can vary day to day.
What are the Harry and Heels donuts at Fourth Man in the Fire?
Harry and Heels California Donuts are the in-house donut program at Fourth Man in the Fire, made fresh daily. A 3-pack is $14.85, a half dozen is $29.90, and a full dozen is $59.85, checked October 22, 2026.
🔗 More Pizza Menus in Canada
Bottom line on Fourth Man in the Fire menu prices: 18-inch pizzas from $25 to $33.50, slices at $7, the Ponzo at $21.50 to $30.50, heroes at $11.49 to $16.99, and fresh daily donuts from $14.85, all CAD. My picks: the Sausage Onion Hot Honey pie, a small Ponzo, and the hot honey dip. Check the official online menu before you go, since prices can change without notice.
