Conspiracy Pizza Menu Prices Canada 2026
Conspiracy Pizza Menu Prices Canada 2026
What Are the Conspiracy Pizza Menu Prices?
Three sizes. That is it. Small, medium (14 inch, 8 slices, feeds two), and XL (18 inches, 12 slices, feeds four). Prices climb predictably across the sizes, and the specialty names repeat at each tier. The smalls are the sweet spot for solo orders. For a one-location shop making its own smoked meats in-house, the pricing is pretty friendly compared to what downtown Toronto charges for thin crust. If you normally order from the big Ontario pizza chains, our guide to Pizzaiolo menu prices in Canada is a useful side-by-side on what the chains charge.
Conspiracy Pizza Menu Prices: Small Pizzas
| Pizza | Price |
|---|---|
| Cheese Tomato sauce, mozzarella |
$11.00 |
| Grassy Knoll | $12.00 |
| Manhattan Project | $12.00 |
| Vegeluxe | $12.00 |
| Pepperoni | $13.00 |
| Deluxe | $13.00 |
| Government Cheese | $13.00 |
| Halifax Inspired by the Halifax donair |
$13.00 |
| Hawaiian | $13.00 |
| Canadian Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, bacon, mushroom |
$13.00 |
| Buffalo White sauce, mozzarella, gouda, smoked chicken, onion, hot sauce |
$13.00 |
| Bay of Pigs White sauce, mozzarella, pulled pork, bacon, red onion, dill pickle, honey mustard |
$13.00 |
| Cowspiracy White sauce, emmental cheese, smoked brisket, red onion, pickled jalapeno, barbecue sauce |
$13.00 |
| Chupacabra Tomato sauce, mozzarella, provolone, Mexican chorizo, mushroom, red onion |
$13.00 |
| Birds Aren’t Real Tomato sauce, mozzarella, provolone, smoked chicken, black and green olives, red onion, garlic oil, oregano |
$13.00 |
| Tour De France | $13.00 |
| Hyper Pep | $14.00 |
Conspiracy Pizza Medium Prices (14 Inch)
| Pizza | Price |
|---|---|
| Cheese | $18.00 |
| Grassy Knoll / Manhattan Project / Vegeluxe | $23.00 |
| All specialty pies Pepperoni, Deluxe, Government Cheese, Halifax, Hawaiian, Canadian, Buffalo, Bay of Pigs, Cowspiracy, Chupacabra, Birds Aren’t Real, Tour De France |
$24.00 |
| Hyper Pep | $25.00 |
Conspiracy Pizza XL Prices (18 Inches)
| Pizza | Price |
|---|---|
| Cheese | $27.00 |
| Vegeluxe | $34.00 |
| Bay of Pigs / Buffalo / Cowspiracy / Deluxe / Government Cheese / Grassy Knoll / Manhattan Project / Pepperoni / Tour De France | $35.00 |
| Birds Aren’t Real / Canadian / Chupacabra / Halifax / Hawaiian / Hyper Pep | $36.00 |
That is the whole menu board in one graphic. Look at how the XL pricing works: everything funnels into $35 or $36 except the Vegeluxe. So if you are deciding between four specialty pies for a group, just pick the one you actually want to eat. The price difference is a dollar.
Small vs Medium vs XL: Which Size Is the Best Deal?
Quick math. A small cheese at $11.00 is the cheapest way to eat here, full stop. The medium cheese at $18.00 for 14 inches and 8 slices is the best per-slice value on the menu, and it feeds two comfortably. The XL cheese at $27.00 for 18 inches feeds four. For specialty pies, the medium at $24.00 is where the value jumps: you get the fun names and the smoked meats at a price most Toronto thin-crust shops would charge for a basic small. If you are ordering for a game night, one XL specialty at $35 to $36 plus a $15 wings order feeds four people well under $60. Not bad at all.
What Else Is on the Conspiracy Pizza Menu?
It is not all pies. They also smoke chicken wings in-house, which is the whole point of the shop’s identity. Ten pieces (a pound) is $15.00, twenty pieces (two pounds) is $25.00. At that price I would take the twenty every time. The dipping sauces run $1.50 each for 50 ml: barbecue, creamy garlic, honey mustard, donair, Illuminhotti hot sauce and Texas Pete. The pickled jalapeno peppers are $2.00, and a full 300 ml bottle of the Illuminhotti hot sauce is $9.00. Drinks are simple: craft sodas like Crush, MUG Root Beer, Brio, Ting and Canada Dry at $2.50 to $3.00, and mineral or sparkling water at $4.00. How does this compare with the bigger wing deals in Ontario? Red Swan Pizza menu prices cover another chain that does pizza plus sides, if you want a second data point.
Conspiracy Pizza Smoked Chicken Wings Prices
The wings are the sleeper item here. Smoked, not just tossed in sauce, and the Illuminhotti hot sauce is the one to get. At $15 for a pound they sit right in line with Toronto pub wings pricing, and honestly the house-smoked angle makes them more interesting than most.
What Is the Story Behind Conspiracy Pizza?
Founder and chef Daniel Rios, Dan to regulars, started Conspiracy Pizza in 2017 after working at Caplansky’s Deli, Milagro Cantina and the Carbon Bar. That kitchen history shows in the menu: the thin, crispy crust is made with Italian pizza flour, and the brisket, bacon and ham are smoked in-house. The shop started at 176 Wicksteed Ave in East York, outgrew the space, and moved to 858 Eglinton Ave E in Leaside, where it shares the storefront with Churnt Up and Phamily Eats. And the names. Grassy Knoll, Manhattan Project, Bay of Pigs, Birds Aren’t Real, Cowspiracy, Chupacabra, Government Cheese. It is a full conspiracy-theory lineup, and I respect the commitment. The Halifax pie nods to the Halifax donair, and the Bay of Pigs is built like a Cubano: pickles plus mustard on a white-sauce base. If the vibe sounds like your thing, the concept is closest in spirit to other playful Ontario pizza shops, like Sarpino’s Pizzeria menu prices for a different take on pizza in the province.
Where Is Conspiracy Pizza in Toronto?
One location. That is the whole footprint: 858 Eglinton Avenue East, Toronto, ON M4G 2L1, in the Leaside neighbourhood on the east side. Phone: +1 647-694-3327. Hours are 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM. Curbside pickup and delivery are both available. Since it is a single shop, the “verify before you go” rule matters more than usual here: hours and prices can shift with no warning, so check the delivery menu before you head over.
Conspiracy Pizza FAQ
What are the Conspiracy Pizza menu prices in Toronto?
Small pies run $11.00 to $14.00, medium 14-inch pizzas are $18.00 to $25.00, and XL 18-inch pizzas run $27.00 to $36.00. Smoked chicken wings are $15.00 for 10 pieces or $25.00 for 20. All prices in CAD, checked October 21, 2026.
Where can I find the conspiracy pizza menu prices online?
Conspiracy Pizza’s own site (conspiracypizza.ca) was unreachable as of October 21, 2026. Current prices are listed on the brand’s official delivery menu (DoorDash), which this guide uses as its source. Delivery-side prices may run a couple of dollars above in-store pickup prices.
What is the Grassy Knoll pizza?
The Grassy Knoll is one of Conspiracy Pizza’s conspiracy-theory-named pies: a small is $12.00, medium is $23.00 and XL is $35.00. Like the Manhattan Project, Bay of Pigs and Cowspiracy, the name is a joke and the pizza is a thin, crispy-crust pie with house-smoked meats.
Is Conspiracy Pizza worth it for thin-crust fans?
If you like a thin, cracker-crisp crust, yes. Conspiracy Pizza bakes on Italian pizza flour and smokes its brisket, bacon and ham in-house, which is rare at this price point. A small cheese is $11.00 and specialty smalls top out at $14.00, so it sits below most downtown Toronto thin-crust shops on price.
What are the cheapest pizzas at Conspiracy Pizza?
The small cheese pizza at $11.00 is the cheapest pie on the menu. Next up are the small Grassy Knoll, Manhattan Project and Vegeluxe at $12.00 each. On the medium menu the cheese 14-inch at $18.00 feeds two and is the best per-slice value.
Does Conspiracy Pizza deliver in Toronto?
Yes. Conspiracy Pizza offers curbside pickup and delivery from 858 Eglinton Avenue East in Leaside, Toronto. Hours are 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM. The brand-managed delivery menu lists the same pies shown in this guide, though delivery prices can run slightly higher than pickup.
Where is Conspiracy Pizza located?
Conspiracy Pizza is at 858 Eglinton Avenue East, Toronto, Ontario, in the Leaside neighbourhood, sharing the storefront with Churnt Up and Phamily Eats. It opened in 2017 at 176 Wicksteed Ave in East York before moving to the current Eglinton spot. Phone: +1 647-694-3327.
Related Menus
That is the complete guide to conspiracy pizza menu prices as of October 2026. The short version I give friends: go small if it is your first visit, get a medium specialty if there are two of you, and do not sleep on the smoked wings. A one-shop pizzeria smoking its own meats at these prices is exactly the kind of Toronto spot worth knowing about.
